I want to introduce you a supercheap mascara that does not smudge. It's from the cheap brand "CoverGirl". It's the red bottle, I've tried so many mascaras, from cheap to super expensive. The best one is still this one. Just make sure you get the red bottle one. The name of it is "CoverGril Super Thick Lash". I've introduced it to all of my friends and they all started using it after they tried it. I think I've used maybe 6 bottles already. It's my favorite one.